The Double-Edged Sword of WhatsApp in South African Workplaces
WhatsApp is now the go-to channel for many South African teams, but its informality masks real legal danger. CCMA awards over the past decade confirm that a single tap can cost an employee their job – and expose the employer to liability – if workplace rules or national laws are breached.
1 Legal Framework
-
Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA) – misconduct on any platform is judged against the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal (Schedule 8). Employers must prove a rule, knowledge of the rule and proportionality of sanction.
-
Cybercrimes Act 19 of 2020 (key parts commenced 1 Dec 2021): criminalises the unlawful interception, disclosure or incitement of violence via electronic messages.
-
Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Act 16 of 2023: signed 24 May 2024; once in force, intentional distribution of hateful content (including in private groups) is punishable by fine or imprisonment. thepresidency.gov.za
-
POPIA 4 of 2013 + RICA 70 of 2002: an employer may inspect or intercept WhatsApp traffic only if the “business exception” in RICA applies or if informed consent is obtained; indiscriminate monitoring of private devices is unlawful. labourguide.co.zamichalsons.com
2 Key CCMA Precedents
| Issue | Award & outcome | Ratio decidendi |
|---|---|---|
| Threats / intimidation | Masondo / AG Electrical (Pty) Ltd (2022) 4 BALR 400 (CCMA) – employee threatened to “kill” the MD in a group chat. Dismissal upheld. ceosa.org.za | Violated rule on violence; destroyed trust; sanction proportional. |
| Racist or offensive speech | Van der Merwe / Momentum STI [2023] 11 BALR 1337 (CCMA) – senior investigator called SA a “baboon government”. Dismissal upheld. linkedin.com | Racism = gross misconduct; employer’s policies clear. |
| Reputational or client harm | Gerber / Xone Control Room Management (Pty) Ltd (2022) 6 BALR 584 (CCMA) – manager posted anti-vaccination views on a client’s WhatsApp group, jeopardising the contract. Dismissal fair. ceosa.org.za | Message harmed commercial relationship; breach of trust. |
| Undermining authority (earlier social media) | Sedick & Another v Krisray (Pty) Ltd (2011) 8 BALR 879 (CCMA) – derogatory Facebook posts about owner; dismissals upheld. allardyce.co.za | Principles apply equally to WhatsApp. |
3 Employer Liability & Monitoring
-
Vicarious liability still applies: if an employee’s message is sent “in the course and scope” of employment (e.g., an official work group), the company can face delictual or statutory claims.
-
Monitoring: only lawful if employees are told in advance and it fits RICA’s “business purpose” or consent requirements. Failure exposes the employer itself to fines up to R2 million or 10 years’ imprisonment. labourguide.co.zabusinesstech.co.za
4 Policy Framework for Employers
-
Digital-communication policy (or add to disciplinary & social-media codes):
-
Scope (work groups, status updates that identify the employer, client groups, etc.)
-
Prohibited content: threats, hate speech, obscene material, confidential data.
-
Reminder that messages are discoverable evidence.
-
-
Training & awareness: annual sessions explaining the above CCMA awards and criminal statutes.
-
Lawful monitoring protocol: written consent in contracts OR reliance on RICA business exception with clear signage and documentation.
-
Consistent discipline: categorise offences (minor, serious, gross) and align sanctions; follow LRA procedural steps.
Conclusion
WhatsApp remains a powerful productivity tool, but CCMA jurisprudence shows it is policed under the same – sometimes stricter – standards as face-to-face conduct. By baking clear rules, lawful monitoring and regular training into their compliance programmes, South African employers can reap the benefits of instant messaging while steering clear of the legal minefield.
Laboured.org.za provides comprehensive labour advisory and consultancy services to South African employers. Contact us at 082 330 3939, email: info@laboured.org.za to develop customized WhatsApp and social media policies for your organization.
Related posts
